The house began as a small one-over-one structure built one of the lot's four 17th-century owners. Corp. John Andrews' White Horse Inn makes a good story, and that's how the house got its name.
In 1742, the 26-year-old kingโs collector visited Marblehead and fell in love with the young tavern maid, a poor fisherman's daughter ten years younger than himself.
The Hayes Hotel was constructed in 1842 as a woolen goods factory. Converted to a tavern and hotel in 1885, the building was being used as a rooming house when it burned in 1969 with a loss of life.